Chapters 9 & 10
Chapter 9 discusses mental health diagnoses. I haven’t seen
it so much lately, but a few years ago, I would consistently see children on my
caseload be diagnosed with ODD. I absolutely despise that diagnosis. It left
the child with this stigma that they can’t be fixed. It labels children as not
being able to function like their peers. It makes me think about how professionals
in the helping field continue to do the same thing over and again expecting a
new outcome. I don’t understand how professionals continue to treat people
without knowing the full story of that person. Chapter 9 also talks about
incest. I can’t imagine the life long impact something like that does to
children. My niece was sexually abused by her older half-brother. She is doing
ok now and has successfully completed individual therapy. But I wonder as she
gets older how her trauma will be revealed in other ways.
Chapter 10 discusses eugenics. The expression of genes
passed down for generations and how those genes present in children/mothers who
have been exposed to trauma. This is great information to have. But it makes me
think about starting intervention from the beginning. I’m talking about birth
control and safe sex education. I’m not talking about rape victims, etc. I
believe that when we are encountering women, education regarding birth control,
and safe sex needs to be a topic. We need to start the intervention prior to
pregnancy. Birth control needs to be free for all women. Education needs to be
presented in a non-judgmental way. If we can attempt to intervene before we
continue multi-generational issues, perhaps we can stop the cycle of trauma
that engrains so deeply in our bodies. I know that is a huge task, but it’s
something I began thinking about in this chapter. I get tired of society putting
road blocks up for women and then blaming us because we couldn’t overcome
something. I currently have a client who is a teenager. She expressed that she
is sexually active. She is living with her maternal aunt and the aunt took her
to a doctor. The mother would only agree to the shot birth control. After
talking with the medical provider, the pill was given to the teen. Now, this mother
has a gamut of issues. But I question why this mother would put a barrier to a
specific kind of birth control. As women we need to empower other women. It’s
disheartening.
Both chapters show how it is extremely hard to change the
minds of people in the professional world. We must use the data that we collect
from studies and from any neuroscience information to help people with the right
intervention for them. I loved reading the statistics in chapter 9 about other
countries. Why is it so hard for the US to model the same thought processes as
other countries?
Nari, I aways appreciate your comments about this book and the passion that it ignites in you! I, too, have many kids on my case load with mood related disorders and after this chapter I definitely questioned the accuracy of these diagnoses. I also agree with you about the importance of sex education. For my undergrad practicum, I interned at Hope House Colorado which was a place for parenting teen moms. I sat in on some of the sex classes that were offered and I was blown away by how many of these teen moms knew very little about birth control options and sex in general. It was quite sad, but I was happy to be apart of that conversation and come away with information that I,too, was unaware of.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the kind words. I'm a firm believer that hormones play a huge role in how children act behaviorally. I still can't find a provider who believes me that I can't handle changes in hormones. So I could never take hormonal birth control because it made me crazy. As we learn about our bodies and mind, it would only make sense that we would also include hormones.
ReplyDeleteGood comments here. I despite the ODD diagnosis too--often resolved with early and quality PCIT. There's a provider in Le Mars that does complete hormone/blood screens. I'll see if I can find her name but it's a great assessment!
ReplyDelete